The item was true to size, the shorts were flattering, and the waistband was comfortable without pinching. However, the liner could use improvement. It doesn't fit like a proper swim bottom— the elastic is thin and digs in, while the liner itself feels loose and baggy. A great improvement would be using a hot-short style liner for better coverage and flat seams that don't pinch. I loved the look and fit of the shorts overall, but returned them due to the liner design.

I have been wearing the Nalu style swim shorts for years and decided to give these a try. I don't care for the skirt-y look in the back nor do I like the zipper pocket in front—the zipper is stiff and scratchy. I do love the color (sea urchin) and exchanges are a pain so I'm going to keep them. However, I'll be going back to the Nalu style when it's time for a new pair.

happy with the coverage and stays in place

Bought a small initially but have wider hips. This an be worn in multiple ways and with multiple swim tops.

These swim shorts are super high quality. I knew from the measurements and some photos that they are very short but was surprised how short. And SO much material in the rear. Have not tried them swimming yet and will do it in private since it seems like I'll be showing a lot of cheek and perhaps ballooning up as I swim. Note: I am an athletic build but that was not a selection option for this review. Still on the hunt for a swim bottom that doesn't show a lot of cheek. Normal bikini bottoms seem to have less and less coverage (including in all the title 9 photos).